After his emphatic victory last weekend, Demetrious 'Mighty Mouse' Johnson staked his claim to being the greatest ever mixed martial artist. And when it comes to considering the question, he's got a point. Not only did he break Anderson Silva's all-time title defences record, as well as maintain a virtually unprecedented UFC win streak of 13, but he has single-handedly destroyed the best of the flyweight division, from Benavidez to Cejudo to Borg.
That got me thinking. To me, to be the best mixed martial artist of all time, the first word is imperative: mixed. While there are countless fighters that are excellent at one, perhaps even two of the skill-sets that make up MMA, there are rarely competitors that satisfy all three components.
So after much consideration, here are my thoughts on the Top 10 UFC Mixed Martial Artists of all time.
Matt Hughes - Welterweight (45-9)
While for many, the term 'dominant welterweight champion' will generate images of a certain French-Canadian, it originated as a description of Illinois-born and bred fighter Matt Hughes. A much celebrated collegiate wrestler, Hughes quickly demonstrated his capabilities with all three of the core techniques of MMA, finishing fights both by submission and strikes.
Amidst iconic rivalries with the likes of Georges St Pierre, BJ Penn, and Frank Trigg, Hughes solidified himself as a true great of the sport, with combined titles reigns lasting more than four years during the 00s. However, perhaps the best indication of his mastery of the various arts is his record, with his 45 wins split evenly between KOs (17), submissions (18) and decisions (10).
Jose Aldo - Featherweight (26-3)
Those who choose to characterise Jose Aldo's career by the 13 seconds that he was inside the Octagon with Conor McGregor are beyond naive, they are ignorant and disrespectful. What this man has done for the lower weight classes is, in my opinion, at least as significant as the likes of Urijah Faber, demonstrating the speed and technique that we are now so familiar with.
Despite his background in Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Aldo is most well known for his striking proficiency, as well as using the environment to his advantage. From his leg-kicking clinic against Faber to beating Mark Hominick so badly his head swelled to twice its size, Aldo is not afraid to make use of all his limbs. His wrestling and clinch work also supports this, perhaps best demonstrated by his dramatic knee knockout of Chad Mendes in 2012.
A ten year undefeated record cannot be ignored, and his abilities both on the ground and on the feet are unquestionable. It's just a shame that he will likely only be remembered for one moment.
Chuck Liddell - Light-Heavyweight (21-8)
With a strong background in wrestling and Brazilian jiu-jitsu, the heavy-handed Iceman was a phenom when he broke onto the scene in the late 90s, and his battles with Tito Ortiz and Randy Couture are now legendary. He was a central part of the growth of the UFC in the 2000s, perhaps just as important as the now iconic TUF 1 Finale fight between Forrest Griffin and Stephan Bonnar.
Having lost his light-heavyweight title at the hands of Quinton 'Rampage' Jackson, a reign that had lasted four defences in nearly two years, the Iceman's career melted. Liddell would go on to lose four of his next five fights, including two of the best brutal knockouts in the company's history.
BJ Penn - Lightweight/Welterweight (16-11-2)
Having burst onto the UFC scene at the tender age of 21, the Hawaiian was fresh off becoming the first American gold medallist at the World Jiu-Jitsu Championships. However, it was his striking that initially helped him shine above the rest, knocking out the likes of Din Thomas and Caol Uno.
As Penn continued to rise, he returned to his basics to gain success, choking out legends including Hughes, Gomi and Pulver, and is one of three fighters to hold belts across two different weight classes. He remains the longest reigning lightweight champion of all time, being undefeated at the class for more than eight years.
The reason that Penn appears so far down the list despite his many accolades is his insistence at fighting way past his prime. In total, the Hawaiian has lost all five of his most recent bouts, stretching back to 2011. While he has consistently fought top 10 lightweights, his powers are fading and he should call it a career before he does more damage.
Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira - Heavyweight (34-10-1)
One of the most iconic PRIDE fighters of all time, who reached the UFC perhaps a few years too late. 'Big Nog' made his name in Japan, fighting everyone from 186lb Jeremy Horn to a steroid-ridden 329lb Bob Sapp. However, Nogueira would become one of the first heavyweights to make use of jiu-jitsu, claiming wins by way of armbar, triangle, anaconda choke, americana and rear naked choke.
Over the coming years Nogueira would fight a who's who of MMA and kickboxing royalty, including Dan Henderson, Fedor Emelianenko, Mirko Cro Cop, Semmy Schilt, Sergei Kharitonov and Fabricio Werdum, before claiming the UFC Interim Heavyweight Championship from Tim Sylvia in 2008.
Sadly, having compiled a record of 29-4-1 prior to entering the UFC, he never hit the heights of his previous form.
Randy Couture - Light-Heavyweight/Heavyweight (19-11)
The only man who has earned a bow of respect from the legendary announcer Bruce Buffer, Randy 'The Natural' Couture, was one of the original UFC legends, and has been credited will some of the growth in the sport's popularity in the 2000s. Switching seamlessly between heavyweight and light-heavyweight, the collegiate wrestler and ex-US military boxer earned a reputation for his dirty boxing approach.
Having already won, lost and vacated the UFC Heavyweight Championship between 1997 and 2002, Couture would become the first man to hold titles across two different weight divisions. He would start an iconic trilogy with fellow Hall of Famer Chuck Liddell, as well as fights with legends like Tito Ortiz and Vitor Belfort, in total winning five separate championships.
Anderson Silva - Middleweight (34-8)
Widely considered by many to be the greatest of all time, 'The Spider' makes only number four on my list. This is for three reasons. Firstly, in his waning years, Silva has lost some of the invincibility that he had between 2006 and 2012. Consecutive losses to Chris Weidman, as well as defeats at the hands of Michael Bisping and Daniel Cormier removed that psychological edge to Silva's game.
Secondly, as a complete mixed martial artist, Anderson has shown he has holes in his game. While he is practically unparalleled on the feet, he has shown a deficiency when it comes to the ground. For four and a half rounds, Silva was completely dominated by Chael Sonnen, before a mistake by the American handed him the opportunity to retain his title.
Finally, Silva has also been the making of his own downfall. Following his unanimous decision victory over Nick Diaz, the Brazilian tested positive for an anabolic steroid, ruling him out for a year and calling all past achievements into contention. Is it a coincidence that he has been a shadow of his former self in the fights since? A victory over Kelvin Gastelum would certainly go some way to righting some of the wrongs, but it is unclear, whether his reputation will ever fully heal.
Georges St-Pierre - Welterweight/Middleweight (25-2)
One of the four dominant champions in the early 2010s alongside Rousey, Jones and Silva, GSP has shown himself to be adept across all of the aspects of mixed martial arts throughout his career. Whether that's the headkick TKO of Matt Hughes to claim his first UFC title, or his ability to utterly shut down the attack of some of the world's greatest strikers - Nick Diaz, Carlos Condit and Johny Hendricks among the challengers pushed back.
The French-Canadian has amassed the largest number of title bout wins in the history of the UFC, as well as the second-longest combined time as champion. His legacy as one of the greatest is secure, but a successful return at UFC 217 could see him enter the conversation as the best fighter to step foot into the Octagon.
Jon Jones - Light-Heavyweight (22-1, 1 NC)
While the aftermath of UFC 214 may have called his previous successes into question, his talent inside the Octagon cannot be questioned. There are few that have been able to innovate in the way that Jon Jones has, and even fewer that have been able to dominate fights both on the feet and the ground.
Think back to his successful spinning elbows on both Stephan Bonnar and Alexander Gustafsson, or his outrageous standing guillotine that sent Lyoto Machida to sleep. Was there always a hint of controversy, either through an eye-poke or personal indiscretion? Sure. But if there was one thing you could guarantee with a Jones fight, it was going to be a spectacle.
While his latest failed drug test could keep him away from the cage for up to four years, there can be no denying that 'Bones' has played a key role in the difficult adolescent period for the sport of mixed martial arts, demonstrating both what and what not to do to the next generation.
Demetrious Johnson - Flyweight (27-2-1)
By head and shoulders the greatest complete technical fighter we have ever seen, particularly following the indiscretions that have hit both Jones and Silva. Over the last five years, the UFC's only flyweight world champion has cleared out his division, with 11 consecutive title defences as part of a 13 fight win streak since a bantamweight world championship defeat to Dominick Cruz.
His win last weekend was perhaps his most impressive to date, utterly dominating a helpless Ray Borg, with the strike count hopelessly one sided. He has also shown his propensity to innovate even under threat, with his picture perfect suplex to armbar combination a shoo-in for Submission of the Year.
For all of Jones' and Silva's style and flair, the basis of Mighty Mouse's success has been pure technique whether on the feet, in the scrambles or on the ground, and as has been proven by the past five years, he truly is unrivalled.
Do you agree with the list? Are there any I've missed? If you want to discuss this, or any of the topics I've discussed, feel free to contact me on Twitter @TheWeighInMMA.
No comments:
Post a Comment